Clinical Microbiology Reviews, July 2000, p. 470-511, Vol. 13, No. 3
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of
Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
0893-8512/00/$04.00+0
Copyright © 2000, American Society for Microbiology. All rights reserved.
Pathogenesis of Group A Streptococcal
Infections
SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
RESURGENCE OF SEVERE GROUP A STREPTOCOCCAL
INFECTIONS AND SEQUELAE
FEATURES OF GROUP A STREPTOCOCCAL SUPPURATIVE INFECTIONS
Pharyngitis and Scarlet Fever
Pyoderma and Streptococcal Skin Infections
Invasive Streptococcal Disease: Streptococcal Toxic Shock
Syndrome, Necrotizing Fasciitis, and Septicemia
Introduction.
Pyrogenic exotoxins and superantigens in invasive disease.
Pyrogenic exotoxin B.
M protein serotypes.
Animal models of invasive soft-tissue infection.
Treatment.
IDENTIFICATION OF THE ORGANISM: OLD AND NEW TECHNIQUES
Description and Clinical Microbiology
Throat culture.
Lancefield group.
M protein and T typing: development of a molecular biology
approach.
Serological Diagnosis of Streptococcal Infection:
Anti-Streptolysin O, Anti-DNase B, and Other Diagnostic Antibodies
PATHOGENESIS: INTERACTION BETWEEN HOST AND PATHOGEN
Adherence and Colonization
Multiple adhesins.
Intracellular Invasion
Host Response to Infection: Opsonization and Phagocytosis
Extracellular Surface Molecules and Virulence Factors
Hyaluronic acid capsule.
M protein.
emm-like genes and the emm gene
superfamily.
Plasminogen-binding proteins: glyceraldhyde-3-phosphate
dehydrogenase, enolase, and streptokinase.
Streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxins and the novel mitogen
SMEZ: role as superantigens.
Streptococcal proteinase (streptococcal exotoxin B).
C5a peptidase.
Streptococcal inhibitor of complement-mediated lysis.
Analysis of the Group A Streptococcal Genome
Global Regulators of Virulence Genes
Determinants of Protective Immunity
Protective opsonic and mucosal antibody against M protein.
Other streptococcal surface components potentially involved
in protection against infection.
T-cell immunity to infection with group A streptococci.
NONSUPPURATIVE SEQUELAE
Acute Poststreptococcal Glomerulonephritis
Introduction.
Diagnosis.
Potential mechanisms of pathogenesis.
Circulating immune complexes.
Molecular mimicry.
Streptococcal antigens and nephritis strain-associated
proteins.
Animal models of poststreptococcal acute
glomerulonephritis.
Rheumatic Fever
Introduction.
Association of group A streptococci with rheumatic fever.
Clinical features of rheumatic fever.
Host susceptibility.
Autoimmunity and Molecular Mimicry in Rheumatic Fever
Autoantibodies cross-reactive with streptococcal antigens.
Molecular mimicry and M protein.
Potential pathogenic mechanisms of cross-reactive
antibodies in rheumatic fever.
Autoreactive T cells in rheumatic fever.
Animal models of carditis.
Streptococcal Reactive Arthritis
Tics and Other Brain Disorders
VACCINATION AND PREVENTION
Antibiotic Therapy and Prophylaxis
Vaccine Strategies
M proteins.
C5a peptidase.
Other vaccine candidates.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
REFERENCES
SUMMARY
|
|
|---|
Group A streptococci are model extracellular gram-positive pathogens responsible for pharyngitis, impetigo, rheumatic fever, and acute glomerulonephritis. A resurgence of invasive streptococcal diseases and rheumatic fever has appeared in outbreaks over the past 10 years, with a predominant M1 serotype as well as others identified with the outbreaks. emm (M protein) gene sequencing has changed serotyping, and new virulence genes and new virulence regulatory networks have been defined. The emm gene superfamily has expanded to include antiphagocytic molecules and immunoglobulin-binding proteins with common structural features. At least nine superantigens have been characterized, all of which may contribute to toxic streptococcal syndrome. An emerging theme is the dichotomy between skin and throat strains in their epidemiology and genetic makeup. Eleven adhesins have been reported, and surface plasmin-binding proteins have been defined. The strong resistance of the group A streptococcus to phagocytosis is related to factor H and fibrinogen binding by M protein and to disarming complement component C5a by the C5a peptidase. Molecular mimicry appears to play a role in autoimmune mechanisms involved in rheumatic fever, while nephritis strain-associated proteins may lead to immune-mediated acute glomerulonephritis. Vaccine strategies have focused on recombinant M protein and C5a peptidase vaccines, and mucosal vaccine delivery systems are under investigation.
INTRODUCTION
|
|
|---|
Streptococcus pyogenes (group A streptococcus) is an important species of gram-positive extracellular bacterial pathogens. Group A streptococci colonize the throat or skin and are responsible for a number of suppurative infections and nonsuppurative sequelae. As pathogens they have developed complex virulence mechanisms to avoid host defenses. They are the most common cause of bacterial pharyngitis and are the cause of scarlet fever and impetigo. The concept of distinct throat and skin strains arose from decades of epidemiological studies, in which it became evident that there are serotypes of group A streptococci with a strong tendency to cause throat infection, and similarly, there are other serotypes often associated with impetigo (62, 543). In the past, they were a common cause of puerperal sepsis or childbed fever. Today, the group A streptococcus is responsible for streptococcal toxic shock syndrome, and most recently it has gained notoriety as the "flesh-eating" bacterium which invades skin and soft tissues and in severe cases leaves infected tissues or limbs destroyed.
The group A streptococcus has been investigated for its significant role in the development of post-streptococcal infection sequelae, including acute rheumatic fever, acute glomerulonephritis, and reactive arthritis. Acute rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease are the most serious autoimmune sequelae of group A streptococcal infection and have afflicted children worldwide with disability and death. Group A streptococcal infections have recently been associated with Tourette's syndrome, tics, and movement and attention deficit disorders. This review will address the potential pathogenic mechanisms involved in poststreptococcal sequelae.
The Lancefield classification scheme of serologic typing distinguished the beta-hemolytic streptococci based on their group A carbohydrate, composed of N-acetylglucosamine linked to a rhamnose polymer backbone. Streptococci were also serologically separated into M protein serotypes based on a surface protein that could be extracted from the bacteria with boiling hydrochloric acid. Currently, more than 80 M protein serotypes have been identified, and a molecular approach to identification of emm (M protein) genes has been achieved. Vaccines containing the streptococcal M protein as well as other surface components are under investigation for prevention of streptococcal infections and their sequelae. This review will focus on the pathogenic mechanisms in group A streptococcal diseases and on new developments which have an impact on our understanding of group A streptococcal diseases in humans.
RESURGENCE OF SEVERE GROUP A STREPTOCOCCAL
INFECTIONS AND SEQUELAE
|
|
|---|
Although group A streptococci are exquisitely sensitive to penicillin, an unexplained resurgence of group A streptococcal infections has been observed since the mid-1980s (275). The first indication that infections due to S. pyogenes were on the rise was an outbreak of rheumatic fever which affected approximately 200 children during a 5-year period (531). From the mid-1980s to the 1990s, eight rheumatic fever outbreaks were documented in the United States, with the largest in Salt Lake City, Utah (17, 275, 531). Outbreaks were reported in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Tennessee, and West Virginia and at the Naval Training Center in San Diego, Calif. (17). A decline in rheumatic fever with a milder disease pattern had been observed in the previous decade (59). Therefore, the increased severity and the attack on middle-class families deviated from the past epidemiological patterns. Streptococcal M protein serotypes associated with the new outbreaks of rheumatic fever were M types 1, 3, 5, 6, and 18 (280).
In the late 1980s, streptococcal toxic shock syndrome, bacteremia, and severe, invasive group A streptococcal skin and soft tissue infections were reported in the United States and Europe (103, 212, 241, 275, 376, 498). Increased bacteremic infections were reported in Colorado, Sweden, and the United Kingdom (93a, 510). These severe and invasive diseases have high morbidity and mortality and may be linked to the emergence of certain serotypes or clonotypes. Although several different M protein serotypes have been isolated from severe, invasive streptococcal diseases, M protein serotype 1 has dominated (241, 245). Host susceptibility may be an important factor in production of toxic streptococcal syndrome. These aspects will be considered in this review. The resurgence of these serious infections and sequelae is strong evidence for increased awareness and surveillance of group A streptococci in the community.
FEATURES OF GROUP A STREPTOCOCCAL SUPPURATIVE INFECTIONS
|
|
|---|
Group A streptococci are extracellular bacterial pathogens which produce a variety of pyogenic infections involving the mucous membranes, tonsils, skin, and deeper tissues, including pharyngitis, impetigo/pyoderma, erysipelas, cellulitis, necrotizing fasciitis, toxic streptococcal syndrome, scarlet fever, septicemia, pneumonia, and meningitis. Infections may be mild to extremely severe. Complications such as sepsis, pneumonia, and meningitis can occur, which may lead to a fatal outcome. Several specific clinical syndromes, such as toxic streptococcal syndrome and necrotizing fasciitis, have reemerged and perhaps become more prevalent in the past 10 years due to infections with S. pyogenes.
Pharyngitis and Scarlet Fever
Group A streptococci are the most common bacterial cause of pharyngitis and primarily affect school-age children 5 to 15 years of age (62). All ages are susceptible to spread of the organism under crowded conditions, such as those at schools and military facilities. Pharyngitis and its association with rheumatic fever are seasonal, occurring in the fall and winter (62, 506, 507). This is in contrast to pyoderma or skin infection, which occurs in the summer and can be associated with the production of acute glomerulonephritis (61). Organisms which colonize the skin can also colonize the throat, but streptococcal strains which commonly produce skin infections do not lead to rheumatic fever. Groups C and G can also cause pharyngitis and must be distinguished from group A organisms after throat culture (58, 62). Although they are not considered normal flora, pharyngeal carriage of group A streptococci can occur without clinical symptoms of disease.
Certain M protein serotypes, such as M types 1, 3, 5, 6, 14, 18, 19, and 24 of S. pyogenes, are found associated with throat infection and rheumatic fever. These pharyngitis-associated serotypes do not produce opacity factor as do M serotypes such as 2, 49, 57, 59, 60, and 61, which are associated with pyoderma and acute glomerulonephritis (60, 62, 506, 507; Facklam, personal communication). The skin and throat serotypes have been divided epidemiologically on the basis of (i) opacity factor production, (ii) the presence of the class I C repeat region epitope identified on M proteins by anti-M protein monoclonal antibody (MAb) 10B6, and (iii) emm (M protein) gene patterns A through E (50, 57).
Although usually associated with streptococcal throat infection, scarlet fever may occur due to infections at other sites (62). The group A streptococcal strain producing scarlet fever does so because it carries the genes for one or more of the streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxins A, B, and C. The genes for exotoxins A and C are encoded on a lysogenic temperate bacteriophage (66, 546), while exotoxin B is chromosomal. The pyrogenic exotoxins, currently known as streptococcal superantigens, are responsible for the rash, strawberry tongue, and desquamation of the skin seen in scarlet fever.
Pyoderma and Streptococcal Skin Infections
Group A streptococci which invade the skin and cause impetigo are different M protein serotypes from those that cause pharyngitis (50, 61, 506, 507). In addition, some of the skin strains are associated with production of acute poststreptococcal glomerulonephritis. The skin infections and nephritis are seasonal, usually occurring during the summer months and in temperate climates. The infection is limited to the epidermis, usually on the face or extremities, and is highly contagious (65). Streptococcal strains which cause pyoderma do not cause rheumatic fever. Staphylococci may be mixed with streptococci in impetigo, and thus the treatment of choice is not penicillin for penicillinase-producing staphylococci (65). Group A streptococcal strains may enter the skin through abrasions and other types of lesions to penetrate the epidermis and produce erysipelas or cellulitis. Erysipelas is a distinctive form of cellulitis with characteristically raised and erythematous superficial layers of the skin, while cellulitis affects subcutaneous tissues (65). Cellulitis may occur from infected burns or wounds. Both erysipelas and cellulitis can be caused by streptococcal groups A, B, C, and G.
Invasive Streptococcal Disease: Streptococcal Toxic Shock Syndrome, Necrotizing Fasciitis, and Septicemia
Introduction. In 1987, Cone and colleagues described a toxic shock-like syndrome due to S. pyogenes (103). Later in 1989, Stevens described an unusually severe form of group A streptococcal disease which was similar to the staphylococcal toxic shock syndrome (498). Streptococcal toxic shock syndrome was characterized by hypotension and multiple organ failure. The Working Group on Severe Streptococcal Infections suggested a case definition of streptococcal toxic shock syndrome and necrotizing fasciitis (569a). Necrotizing fasciitis may accompany the toxic streptococcal syndrome. Group A streptococcal infection producing the toxic syndrome may occur in muscle and fascia and follow mild trauma with entrance of streptococci through the skin. In addition, group A streptococci may infect the vaginal mucosa and uterus, leading to severe disease or septicemia. Several excellent recent reviews on severe invasive streptococcal disease report on its features and pathogenesis (3, 290, 379, 498). The features of invasive streptococcal infections include hypotension and shock, multiple organ failure, systemic toxicity, severe local pain, rapid necrosis of subcutaneous tissues and skin, and gangrene (65). Predisposing factors include skin trauma, surgery, varicella, and burns.
Pyrogenic exotoxins and superantigens in invasive disease.
Several virulence factors of group A streptococci are likely to be
involved in the pathogenesis of toxic shock, invasion of soft tissues
and skin, and necrotizing fasciitis. These virulence factors are the
extracellular pyrogenic exotoxins A, B, and C as well as newly
discovered exotoxins and superantigens such as exotoxin F (mitogenic
factor) and streptococcal superantigen (SSA) (366, 394,
395). In addition, several new superantigens with strong
mitogenic activity have recently been reported as SpeG, SpeH, SpeJ,
SmeZ, and SmeZ-2 (274, 434). Details about the mitogenic toxins are described in a separate section under virulence factors. These new data point to the fact that there are a large number of
superantigens which may play a role in toxic streptococcal syndrome.
All of these toxins act as superantigens which interact with major
histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules and a limited
number of V
regions of the T-lymphocyte receptor to activate massive
numbers of T cells nonspecifically. The activation liberates large
amounts of interleukins as well as other inflammatory cytokines such as
tumor necrosis factor and gamma interferon (171, 221, 395).
The pyrogenic exotoxins are potentially responsible for at least some
of the manifestations of toxic streptococcal syndrome. Kotb and
colleagues demonstrated evidence for selective depletion of T cells
expressing V
1, V
5.1, and V
12 in patients with streptococcal
toxic shock syndrome, further supporting the hypothesis that the
streptococcal superantigens play an important role in disease
pathogenesis (544). Further evidence also suggests that
streptococcal isolates from toxic streptococcal syndrome induce a Th1
rather than a Th2 cytokine response, which is characteristic of
superantigens (393).
Pyrogenic exotoxin B.
Pyrogenic exotoxin B is an
extracellular cysteine protease which has been shown to cleave
fibronectin and vitronectin (288), extracellular matrix
proteins, and human interleukin-1
into the active form of the
molecule (287). Therefore, the protease may be important in
inflammation, shock, and tissue destruction. Humans with a diverse
range of invasive disease (erysipelas, cellulitis, pneumonia,
bacteremia, septic arthritis, toxic shock syndrome, and necrotizing
fasciitis) all produced elevated levels of antibodies against
streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxin B following infection (214).
M protein serotypes. M protein serotypes are nonrandomly represented among invasive-disease-causing strains (91, 100, 102, 369, 377, 378, 381, 389, 482). In clinical reports and epidemiological studies of invasive and toxic streptococcal diseases, M types 1, 3, 11, 12, and 28 have frequently been reported, with M1 and M3 being the most common. Other serotypes have occasionally been reported. Using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) as detected in pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, two subclones from invasive disease were identified by RFLP type and multilocus enzyme electrophoretic type (377, 378). The M1T1 genotype was recovered from both invasive disease and uncomplicated pharyngitis, suggesting that host factors as well as the streptococcal strain play a role in the development of severe disease (369, 379). The M1T1 genotype was studied during a recent epidemic in Sweden; the conclusion was that M1T1 did not appear to be clonal, since it had genetic diversity downstream of the emm-1 gene and both genes for erythrogenic toxins A and B exhibited clonal variation (389). This was in contrast to findings reported by Cleary and others that M1 may be clonotypic (100). Recent data reported by Stockbauer and colleagues (500) show that invasive M1 organisms are a heterogeneous array of related organisms that differ by variation in the streptococcal inhibitor of complement.
Animal models of invasive soft-tissue infection. Wessels and colleagues have developed a murine model of human invasive soft-tissue infection (16). The animals challenged with wild-type M3 streptococci developed a spreading soft-tissue necrosis, with bacteremia and death. Animals challenged with acapsular or M protein-deficient M3 mutants did not develop the spreading, necrotizing disease but developed a localized abscess. In further studies, mutants of the M3 strain from which the cysteine protease gene was deleted caused the same necrosis and spreading disease as the wild type. Therefore, in the murine model of soft-tissue infection described by Ashbaugh et al. (16), the capsule and M protein play a major role in development of the spreading necrotic lesion.
Boyle has utilized an air sac model of skin infection in an attempt to demonstrate an association between expression of immunoglobulin G (IgG)-binding proteins and invasive potential (71, 442, 467). In recent studies, Raeder and Boyle have shown that fresh clinical M1 serotype isolates from blood cultures could be subgrouped based on their invasive potential in the mouse skin air sac model and IgG-binding protein expression (442). The expression of M1 protein and its IgG-binding properties were associated with the invasive potential of the M1 serotype studied. Subtle differences in the M1 serotype have been reported previously which may affect the invasive potential of the M1 strain (225). The virulence of an isolate in the skin model does not necessarily correlate with virulence potential when the streptococcal strain is administered intraperitoneally (71, 442, 467). In the skin air sac model of group A streptococcal infection, phenotypic variation of the same M protein serotype alters virulence. The skin models of infection and invasion suggest that the virulence factors required for skin invasion may be different from those for invasion through the pharyngeal route of infection or by injection intraperitoneally, which bypasses the normal entrance mechanisms of the bacterium. The section on virulence factors in this review will address some of these issues.Treatment. Treatment of toxic and severe invasive disease with antibiotics is not always effective, and mortality can exceed 50% (149). The failure of penicillin to treat severe invasive streptococcal infections successfully is attributed to the phenomenon that a large inoculum reaches stationary phase quickly and penicillin is not very effective against slow-growing bacteria (497, 499). Treatment with clindamycin in experimental models of fulminant streptococcal infections appears to be more efficacious than penicillin, but this has not yet been demonstrated in humans. Clindamycin acts on protein synthesis rather than on cell wall synthesis.
A number of studies have suggested that treatment of streptococcal toxic shock syndrome with intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) reduces the mortality rate (291, 292, 494). The reason for this may be that IVIG provides neutralizing or protective antibody to the patient. Plasma from patients with severe invasive group A streptococcal infections who were given IVIG inhibited streptococcal superantigen-induced T-cell proliferation and cytokine production (392). All three streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxins, A, B, and C, were inhibited by the IVIG. The data suggested that a deficiency of neutralizing antibodies against the superantigens may increase the risk of developing disease (23, 24). In addition, opsonic antibodies against M1 protein were found in pooled IVIG, and the anti-M1 antibodies combined with superantigen neutralizing antibodies in the IVIG should contribute to decreased mortality by reducing the bacterial load and neutralizing the effects of the toxins in patients with severe disease (24).
IDENTIFICATION OF THE ORGANISM: OLD AND NEW TECHNIQUES
|
|
|---|
Description and Clinical Microbiology
Throat culture. The group A streptococci have long been recognized as the Streptococcus sp. associated with acute pharyngitis. In a positive throat culture, group A streptococci appear as beta-hemolytic colonies among other normal throat flora which are usually alpha- or nonhemolytic on 5% sheep blood agar. S. pyogenes may appear as highly mucoid to nonmucoid; colonies are catalase negative. Optimal recovery of group A streptococci may be achieved by use of blood agar plates containing sulfamethoxazole-trimethoprim to inhibit some of the normal flora and growth under anaerobic conditions to enhance streptolysin O activity (303). Throat culture is still recognized as the most reliable method for detecting the presence of group A streptococci in the throat (170). Presumptive identification of the beta-hemolytic group A streptococci relies on susceptibility to bacitracin or a positive pyrrolidonylarylamidase test (170).
Lancefield group.
The Lancefield serological grouping
system for identification of streptococci is based on the immunological
differences in their cell wall polysaccharides (groups A, B, C, F, and
G) or lipoteichoic acids (group D) (303). The group A
carbohydrate antigen is composed of
N-acetyl-
-D-glucosamine linked to a polymeric rhamnose backbone. Confirmation of S. pyogenes is done by
highly accurate serological methods, such as the Lancefield capillary precipitin technique and the slide agglutination procedure, which utilize standardized grouping antisera (170). These methods, including Streptex on primary plates (24 h) or subculture (48 h), would
confirm group A streptococci. For this reason, rapid tests which screen
for the presence of group A streptococci in the throat have been
developed and are popular in the clinical setting (170,
303). Facklam has recently reviewed the currently available group
A screening tests and discusses their sensitivity and specificity in
comparison with the conventional methods (170). It is beyond
the scope of this review to describe the many tests available for
identification of group A streptococci from throat swabs. However, the
most rapid tests take 5 to 30 min and use some form of nitrous acid or
enzymatic extraction of the group A carbohydrate (170).
Fluorescent-antibody and genetic probe tests can be performed directly
on throat swabs but are not easily adapted to the clinical setting.
Once extracted, the group A carbohydrate antigen is detected by one of
four methods, including slide agglutination, enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA), optical immunoassay, and a modified
one-step ELISA procedure (170).
M protein and T typing: development of a molecular biology approach. Streptococcal M protein, which extends from the cell membrane of group A streptococci, has been used to divide S. pyogenes into serotypes. Quite a number of years ago, Lancefield designed a serotyping system for the identification of the M protein serotypes (317). The method consisted of treating group A streptococci grown in Todd-Hewitt broth with boiling 0.1 N HCl. This method extracted the group A carbohydrate, M protein, and cell wall, and the clarified extract was used in capillary precipitin tests to determine the M protein serotype with standardized typing sera. The N-terminal region of the M protein has been demonstrated to contain the type-specific moiety and is recognized by specific typing sera in the precipitin test (28, 179, 271, 318). There were several difficulties with M serotyping, including ambiguities in the results, discovery of new M types, difficulty in obtaining high-titered antisera against opacity factor-positive strains, and the availability and high cost of preparing high-titered antisera for all known serotypes (170). Currently, more than 80 different serotypes of M protein have been identified (170).
Because of the difficulty in preparation of M-typing antisera, an alternative to the preparation of M-typing antisera has been developed (518, 559, 560). Approximately half of group A streptococci produce opacity factor, a lipoproteinase which causes various types of mammalian serum to increase in opacity. Antibodies against the opacity factor are type specific and correlate with the M type. By using an opacity factor inhibition test, the M type of a group A streptococcus can be determined by determining the type of opacity factor (518, 559, 560). The T protein antigen is present at the surface of the group A streptococci along with the M and R protein antigens. Although the genes for the M (see section on M protein) and T proteins (272, 470) have been investigated, the R protein sequence has not been elucidated. Although there is homology between tee genes, there is a much greater diversity among them compared with emm genes (272). Unlike the M protein, the most conserved region appeared to reside in the amino-terminal half of the T protein molecule. These observations were made from comparison of 25 different T types (272). In addition, the T protein was not present in streptococcal groups C and G. In the laboratory, the T typing assay is performed as an agglutination test. The T typing of group A streptococci has been important in the investigation of epidemiology of group A streptococcal infections and has identified strains associated with outbreaks when the M type was not identifiable. Because certain M and emm types are associated with certain T types, the testing for M or emm type can be shortened by knowledge of the T type. Most (>95%) group A streptococci have well-defined T-type antigens, and certain T serotypes are associated with each of the specific M protein serotypes (34, 36). The use of T typing in addition to emm gene sequence analysis allows the identification of strain diversity. This type of characterization of group A streptococcal isolates is extremely important in the current climate of emerging invasive disease and sequelae. Recently, a molecular biology approach has been developed for the identification of M protein serotypes (35). In this study, the emm types of 95 known M serotypes (reference strains) and 74 of 77 clinical isolates were identified by rapid PCR analysis. A nucleotide primer pair was used for amplification and identification of the emm allele. Of the 95 reference strains analyzed, 81 closely matched sequences in GenBank, 5 were new gene sequences added to GenBank, and the rest had small discrepancies which will be resolved. In general, a good correlation was seen between the known serotype and the identification by emm gene sequencing by the rapid PCR technique. This technique has advantages over hybridization techniques, where problems arise in identification of new genes or hybrid M protein molecules which result from interstrain recombination (553). Recently, rapid hybridization techniques utilizing emm-specific oligonucleotide probes have been shown to be useful in identification of M protein serotypes (289). Information on emm types can be accessed through the internet at http://www.cdc.gov/hcidod/biotech/infotech_hp.html.Serological Diagnosis of Streptococcal Infection: Anti-Streptolysin O, Anti-DNase B, and Other Diagnostic Antibodies
The host responds immunologically to streptococcal infection with a plethora of antibodies against many streptococcal cellular and extracellular components. Host responses against the M protein serotype protect against reinfection with that particular serotype. Routinely, serotype-specific antibodies are measured only for research purposes and not for diagnosis of streptococcal infection. Responses against other cellular components are observed, including antibodies against the cell wall mucopeptide, the group A streptococcal carbohydrate moieties N-acetylglucosamine and rhamnose, and the other protein cell wall antigens R and T. None of the cell wall antigens are used in the routine diagnosis of group A streptococcal infections.
Serological diagnosis of group A streptococcal infections is based on
immune responses against the extracellular products streptolysin O,
DNase B, hyaluronidase, NADase, and streptokinase, which induce strong
immune responses in the infected host (507). Anti-streptolysin O (ASO) is the antibody response most often examined
in serological tests to confirm antecedent streptococcal infection.
Todd developed the assay for ASO antibodies by 1932 (520).
An increase in the ASO titer of
166 Todd units is generally accepted
as evidence of a group A streptococcal infection. In previous studies
it has been shown that infants are born with maternal levels of
antistreptococcal antibodies and that infants develop streptococcal
infections after the first year of life. ASO antibodies may not
demonstrate a detectable rise in 1- to 3-year-olds, who have had few
previous group A streptococcal infections (349). At <2
years of age, >50% of the patients had ASO titers of <50 Todd units,
and none of the patients had titers above 166 (349). In the
same study, older school-age children developed higher ASO titers. All
five of the extracellular streptococcal enzymes may become
significantly elevated over normal levels during a streptococcal
infection. Although the ASO titer is the standard serological assay for
confirmation of a group A streptococcal infection, assay of several of
the enzymes enhances the chance for a positive test if the patient did
not produce high levels of antibody against one or more of the
extracellular enzymes. In general, the titers of antibodies against the
extracellular products parallel each other; however, exceptions may be
seen in infections with pyoderma or nephritogenic strains, when the anti-DNase B titers have been found to be a reliable indicator of
streptococcal infection (507). Infection of the skin does not always elicit a strong ASO response.
Confirmation of a group A streptococcal infection is imperative for the diagnosis of rheumatic fever, since most often streptococci cannot be cultured from the pharynx. In rheumatic fever, approximately 80% of the patients will have an elevated ASO titer (>200 Todd units) at 2 months after onset (61). If an anti-DNase B or antihyaluronidase assay is performed on sera from these patients, the number of patients with at least one positive antistreptococcal enzyme titer rises to 95%. Thus, most acute rheumatic fever cases demonstrate an elevated ASO titer with some exceptions which require more than one antibody test to detect previous group A streptococcal infection. The streptozyme test was developed some years ago as a hemagglutination assay for the detection of multiple antibodies against extracellular products such as anti-streptolysin O, anti-DNase B, antihyaluronidase, antistreptokinase, or anti-NADase, and it is used clinically in some laboratories as an additional diagnostic test (61).
PATHOGENESIS: INTERACTION BETWEEN HOST AND PATHOGEN
|
|
|---|
Adherence and Colonization
Host-pathogen interactions occur due to binding of surface streptococcal ligands to specific receptors on host cells. Attachment of group A streptococci to pharyngeal or dermal epithelial cells is the most important initial step in colonization of the host. Without strong adherence mechanisms, group A streptococci could not attach to host tissues and would be removed by mucous and salivary fluid flow mechanisms and exfoliation of the epithelium. In skin attachment and colonization by group A streptococci, a site of previous damage may be important in overcoming the dermal barrier. Specific adhesion allows competition between normal flora and group A streptococci for tissue sites where normal flora reside. The investigation of adherence determinants of both streptococcal and host cells is vital to the understanding of pathogenic mechanisms in disease and in the development of antiadhesive therapies or vaccines to prevent colonization. Immunization or exposure of humans or animals to microbial adhesins may induce antibodies which concentrate in the mucosal layer and block adherence and colonization at the mucosal epithelium.
The adhesion process involves multiple group A streptococcal adhesins reported by several investigators as detailed below and described in excellent reviews (19, 108, 226, 227). Adherence has been outlined in these reviews as an initial weak interaction with the mucosa which is followed by a second adherence event which confers tissue specificity and high-avidity adherence (227). In addition, one could speculate that the presence of multiple adhesins in strains could give them the advantage of more avid adherence and potentially enhanced virulence. Although not yet well understood, environmental factors expressed in a particular body site may be important cues for expression of adhesins important for colonization of a tissue-specific site. It is possible that movement of streptococci from the mucosa or skin into deeper tissues may be facilitated by specialized adhesion mechanisms. Recent studies indicate that adherence to particular types of host cells may induce localized cytokine production and inflammatory responses (110, 536).
Multiple adhesins.
In early studies of bacterial
adherence, Ellen and Gibbons suggested that an adhesin was associated
with the M protein fimbriae on the surface of the group A streptococci
(168, 169). Shortly thereafter, Beachey and Ofek published
the first paper describing lipoteichoic acid (LTA) as an adhesin
(27). Their data suggested that M protein was not the
adhesin, but that LTA, an amphipathic molecule, was the adhesin for
buccal epithelial cells. In these first studies of LTA, experiments
characterizing adhesion were established (27). Antibody
against LTA on the group A streptococci blocked adhesion to epithelial
cells, and LTA, when reacted with epithelial cells, saturated the
epithelial cell adhesin and inhibited adherence. Later, fibronectin was
identified as the epithelial cell receptor binding LTA
(488). In these studies, fibronectin was found to inhibit
adhesion of group A streptococci to epithelial cells, and
antifibronectin was found to block the binding of streptococci to
epithelial cells. The LTA molecule was found to act as an adhesin by
reacting with molecules on the streptococcal surface, such as the M
protein, through its negatively charged polyglycerol phosphate backbone
and positively charged residues of surface proteins. The lipid moiety
of LTA projected outward and interacted with fatty acid-binding sites
on fibronectin and epithelial cells (397). Evidence
suggested that LTA accounted for approximately 60% of adhesion to
epithelial cells, indicating that other adhesins were involved in the
adherence of group A streptococci to epithelial cells. In a recent
review (226), Hasty and Courtney state that at least 11 adhesins have been described for group A streptococci, including M
protein (90, 136, 168, 169, 401, 540), LTA (106, 109,
111, 398, 488, 489), protein F/Sfb (223, 224), a
29-kDa fibronectin-binding protein (105),
glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (412, 563), a
70-kDa galactose-binding protein (201, 535), a
vitronectin-binding protein (526), a collagen-binding protein (533), serum opacity factor (310), a
54-kDa fibronectin binding-protein, FBP54 (109), and the
hyaluronate capsule (549). Several extracellular host cell
proteins have been implicated in attachment or adherence to group A
streptococci, including fibronectin (105, 488), fibrinogen
(463), collagen (533), vitronectin
(526), a fucosylated glycoprotein (541), and
integral membrane proteins including CD46, the membrane cofactor
protein on keratinocytes (400), and CD44, the
hyaluronate-binding receptor on keratinocytes (471). Table
1 summarizes the streptococcal adhesins
and host receptors described previously.
|
Intracellular Invasion
In the past few years, new evidence suggested that group A
streptococci not only adhere to epithelial cells but also invade them
(324). LaPenta and colleagues demonstrated that group A streptococci have the potential to invade human epithelial cells at
frequencies equal to or greater than classical intracellular bacterial
pathogens, such as Listeria and Salmonella spp.
(324). This initial report generated considerable interest
and was confirmed by several laboratories (187, 211, 261,
365). Figure 1 illustrates invasion
of epithelial cells by group A streptococci (187).
High-frequency invasion requires expression of M protein
(118) and/or fibronectin-binding proteins such as SfbI
(261, 365). Both the M1 protein and SFbI are considered
invasins because latex beads coated with either protein are efficiently
internalized by epithelial cells. In addition, mutations in genes that
encode these proteins reduce the capacity of streptococci to invade
cultured cells. Most recent work has demonstrated high-frequency
intracellular invasion of epithelial cells by the M1 serotype of group
A streptococci (160). The investigation demonstrated
cytoskeletal rearrangements within the cells during the invasion
process.
|
Fibronectin (118) and high-affinity fibronectin-binding
proteins (406) trigger invasion by engagement of
5
1
integrin receptors on epithelial cells. Group A streptococci can invade
human cells by other mechanisms. Laminin has been shown to bind group A
streptococci (515) and will induce ingestion of M1
streptococci, independent of serum and fibronectin. Small peptides with
the RGD amino acid sequence stimulate uptake in the absence of serum
and M protein. The fact that group A streptococci evolved multiple
routes to the interior of epithelial cells is a strong indication that
intracellular invasion plays an important role in their pathogenesis.
The most direct evidence that intracellular invasion is more than a
laboratory phenomenon comes from studies of patients with recurrent
tonsillitis. Failure to eradicate streptococci from the throat in
pharyngotonsillitis occurs in approximately 30% of cases (348,
421). Osterlund and colleagues showed that tonsils excised from
such individuals harbored intracellular group A streptococci
(403). Others report that strains isolated from carriers are
exceptionally able to invade HEp-2 cells in vitro (364). The
reason for invasion of host cells is not entirely clear, although the
streptococci may find the intracellular environment to be a good place
to avoid host defense mechanisms. Therefore, internalization of
streptococci may lead to carriage and persistence of streptococcal
infection. In further studies, an association of the presence of the
fibronectin-binding gene prtF1 with streptococcal strains
from antibiotic treatment failures was found (383). In the
treatment failures, 92.3% of the strains contained the
prtF1 gene, while 29.6% of strains from eradicated
infections did not.
Two theories have been proposed for the role of internalization of group A streptococci in disease pathogenesis. It has been suggested to potentially play a role in the carriage and persistence of streptococci, as stated above. Second, studies suggest that internalization may lead to invasion of deeper tissues (324), while other studies have found that low virulence was associated with internalization (472). Perhaps both theories are correct depending on the virulence and properties of the invading bacterium and whether the invasion is of the throat or skin epithelium. It is also possible that internalization of group A streptococci by host epithelial cells represents successful containment of the pathogen by the host. This hypothesis is supported by the observation that poorly encapsulated strains are internalized most efficiently but are relatively avirulent in infection models (472). Future study of these and other questions about intracellular invasion will no doubt yield new and unexpected clues to the role of internalization in the pathogenesis of group A streptococci.
Host Response to Infection: Opsonization and Phagocytosis
It is well established that group A streptococci are antiphagocytic due to surface exposed M protein and hyaluronic acid capsule (368, 551). Two mechanisms have been proposed to explain the antiphagocytic behavior of M-positive streptococci. One mechanism is the binding of factor H, which inhibits the activation of the complement pathway (246). Factor H is a regulatory component of the complement pathway, which inhibits the deposition of soluble C3b. Factor H binds to the C repeat region of the M proteins, and deletion of the C1 and C2 repeat regions reduces factor H binding (418).
The antiphagocytic behavior of group A streptococci is also mediated by
the binding of fibrinogen to the surface of M protein (555-557). Fibrinogen binding to the surface of group A
streptococci blocks the activation of complement via the alternate
pathway and greatly reduces the amount of C3b bound to streptococci,
which therefore reduces phagocytosis by polymorphonuclear leukocytes (247). Type-specific M protein antibodies overcome this
effect by binding to the exposed N-terminal M protein epitopes. This results in activation of the classical complement pathway, deposition of C3b, and subsequent phagocytosis. Figure
2 illustrates opsonization of group A
streptococci by M type-specific antibody and complement.
|
In addition to the antiphagocytic properties of the M protein, other surface molecules contribute to resistance to phagocytosis by the group A streptococcus. Recent studies have shown that mutations in Mrp (M-related protein) affect resistance to phagocytosis compared with wild-type strains, and in fact, insertion mutations in any one of the genes emm-49, enn-49, and mrp-49 resulted in reduced resistance to phagocytosis in human blood and purified polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) (425). From these results Podbielski suggested that resistance to phagocytosis depended on the cooperative effects of all three genes. Further studies by Ji, Cleary, and colleagues confirmed this hypothesis by demonstrating that failure to produce all three M-like proteins, M49, Mrp, and Enn-49, reduced resistance to phagocytosis but did not alter the persistence of streptococci at the oral mucosa (266).
It was found that C5a-activated PMNs were able to kill M-positive streptococci. It has been shown previously that C5a alters the clearance and trafficking of group A streptococci during infection (265). By inactivating C5a, C5a peptidase blocks chemotaxis of PMNs and mononuclear phagocytes to the site of infection (265, 552), while the M protein is limiting the deposition of complement on the surface of the streptococci (260). Therefore, the multiple mechanisms involved in resistance to phagocytosis in a bacterium where antiphagocytic behavior is essential for survival may have only recently been appreciated.
Extracellular Surface Molecules and Virulence Factors
The group A streptococci are covered with an outer hyaluronic acid
capsule (298), while the group A carbohydrate antigen and
the type-specific M protein are attached to the bacterial cell wall and
membrane, as shown in Fig. 3. Both the M
protein and the capsule are considered virulence factors conferring
antiphagocytic properties upon the streptococcal cell (179, 189,
368).
|
Hyaluronic acid capsule. The group A streptococcal capsule is composed of a polymer of hyaluronic acid containing repeating units of glucuronic acid and N-acetylglucosamine (509). Synthesis of the polymer involves the products of three genes, hasA, hasB, and hasC, which are all in the same operon (161). The hasA gene encodes hyaluronate synthase (152, 163); hasB encodes UDP-glucose dehydrogenase (162); and hasC encodes UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase (112). The expression of the has genes is transcriptionally controlled. The three has genes are transcribed as a single message from the promotor upstream of hasA (113). However, only hasA and hasB are required for capsule expression in group A streptococci (15).
The hyaluronic acid capsule is required for resistance to phagocytosis (549). Acapsular mutant strains were altered in their virulence and colonization capacities in animal models (256, 466, 549). Acapsular mutants of serotypes M18 and M24 had drastically reduced virulence in mice after intraperitoneal challenge (549, 551). In a mouse model of skin infection, encapsulated M24 strain Vaughn produced dermal necrosis with purulent inflammation and bacteremia, while the acapsular M 24 strain produced no lesions or minor superficial inflammation with no bacteremia (472). In addition, the capsule may be an important adherence factor in the pharynx, since it binds CD44 on epithelial cells (471). Streptococcal isolates vary in the amount of hyaluronic acid capsule that they produce, which could be related to the has operon promotor. The promoter was more active in a well-encapsulated strain and less active in a poorly encapsulated strain (8). Most recently, Levin and Wessels have demonstrated a negative regulator (CsrR) of hyaluronate synthesis which is part of a two-component regulatory system influencing capsule production and virulence (327). Epidemiologic evidence linking highly mucoid strains with rheumatic fever and severe invasive streptococcal disease suggests that the capsule could play an important role in invasive infections in humans (267). The studies described above also recognize the capsule as a major virulence determinant in conjunction with the streptococcal M protein. Studies of type 18 and type 24 streptococci indicated that the hyaluronate capsule and M proteins were variably important in resistance of different group A streptococci to phagocytosis and that opsonization with C3 did not always lead to phagocytosis and killing (146). Although hyaluronic acid is identical to the polysaccharide in bovine vitreous humor and human umbilical cord and has been defined as a weak immunogen due to similarity to self, immunization of animals has been shown to elicit antihyaluronate antibodies (175, 176). The fact that the capsule is antiphagocytic and promotes resistance to phagocytosis is supported by data demonstrating that hyaluronidase treatment of encapsulated streptococci increases their susceptibility to phagocytosis (190, 457). However, anticapsule antibody is not opsonic and does not protect against infection by neutralizing the antiphagocytic effects of the capsule. More recent work provides definitive evidence that the capsule is a major virulence determinant involved in resistance to phagocytosis (146, 368, 550). The mechanism of resistance to phagocytosis does not appear to be due to effects on the amount of complement component C3 deposited on the surface of the streptococci (146). The mechanism may be due to the physical barrier of the capsule in preventing access of phagocytes to opsonic complement proteins bound to the bacterial surface.M protein.
The group A streptococcal M proteins have
been studied extensively since their discovery (317-320).
Two excellent comprehensive reviews by Fischetti describe the
characteristics of the M protein molecule in detail (177,
179). The M protein is a major surface protein and virulence
factor of group A streptococci, with more than 80 distinct serotypes
identified. The amino-terminal region extends from the surface of the
streptococcal wall, while the carboxy-terminal region is within the
membrane. The M protein is anchored in the cell membrane by the LPSTGE
motif identified by Fischetti and colleagues (183). The M
protein extends from the cell surface as an alpha-helical coiled-coil
dimer which appears as fibrils on the surface of group A streptococci
(419) (Fig. 4).
|
|
emm-like genes and the emm gene
superfamily.
Genes related to the M protein gene (emm)
are called the M gene superfamily and include immunoglobulin-binding
proteins, M-related proteins, and M proteins. These proteins may
possess functional properties of immunoglobulin binding or
antiphagocytic behavior. According to Hollingshead and colleagues
(238), more than 20 genes have been identified in the
emm gene superfamily, in which the genes shared greater than
70% DNA sequence identity at their 5' ends (238). The
highly conserved identity is found within three distinct domains in the
cell-associated region of the M protein molecule. These domains include
domain H, which may serve to anchor the protein in the membrane; the
peptidoglycan-associated domain; and the cell wall-associated domain.
The domains are all highly conserved among emm gene products
compared with the other regions of the molecules which are surface
exposed (238). These domains do not include the C repeat
region of M proteins, which can be divided into class I and class II M
proteins depending on the presence of the class I epitope detected by
MAb 10B6 and others (50, 52). Phylogenetic analysis of the
region has revealed four major lineages, designated subfamilies SF1
through SF4, that contain differences in the peptidoglycan-spanning
domain of the M or M-like protein (53, 238, 239). Five major
emm chromosomal patterns of the subfamily genes were
identified based on the number and arrangement of the emm
subfamily genes (56). These subfamily gene arrangement
patterns were designated A through E. A given strain has one, two, or
three emm or emm-like genes that are tandemly arranged on the chromosome near the positive transcriptional regulator called the multiple gene regulator of group A streptococci
(mga). The emm gene patterns display several
phenotypes. Table 2 summarizes the
patterns of emm genes associated with skin and throat
infections.
|
|